The page you are reading is part of a draft (v2.0) of the "No bullshit guide to math and physics."

The text has since gone through many edits and is now available in print and electronic format. The current edition of the book is v4.0, which is a substantial improvement in terms of content and language (I hired a professional editor) from the draft version.

I'm leaving the old wiki content up for the time being, but I highly engourage you to check out the finished book. You can check out an extended preview here (PDF, 106 pages, 5MB).


Cardinal numbers

Consider the set of natural numbers $\mathbb{N}=\{0,1,2,3,\ldots\}$. There is a countably $\aleph_0$

Claim: $\aleph_0 \neq \aleph_1$

Proof: We

Consider some set $X$ and its power set $2^X$. Let the cardinality of $|X|=\aleph_0$

Define $f$ to be some set function, which associates a subset of $X$ to each element $x \in X$. \[ x \to f(x). \] To show $\aleph_0 \neq \aleph_1$, we have to show that there is no bijection between the set and its powerset (since $\aleph_1$ is identified as the cardinality of the powerset of a set of cardinality $\aleph_0$).

We give a proof by contradiction. Assume that a bijection $f$ exists, and consider the subset of $X$ which consists of all elements which are not contained in their image under $f$. \[ Y = \{ x \in X \ | \ x \not \in f(x) \}, \qquad \qquad (1) \] which means that: \[ \forall y \in Y, y \not \in f(y). \qquad \qquad (2) \]

Now if $f$ is a bijection, then there must be some $\tilde{y} \in X$ that is the pre-image of $Y$, such that: \[ f(\tilde{y}) = Y. \]

Now we ask the question: “is $\tilde{y} \in Y$? ”
If yes, then we get a contradiction with $(2)$. If no, then this means $\tilde{y} \not in f(\tilde{y})$ and from the definition of the set $Y$ in $(1)$, $\tilde{y}$ should have been included in $Y$. So we have a contradiction, and $f$ must not exists.

On the other hand, we have the trivial injection $g$ which assigns to each element of a set the set with the single element: \[ g(x) = \{ x \}, \forall x \in X. \]

Therefore we have shown that there is an injection from $X$ to its powerset, but there is no bijection, hence the cardinality of the set $X$ must differ from the cardinality of its powerset. By definition, we call this next cardinality $\aleph_1$.

Sidenote

There is a bijection between the reals $(0,1)$ and subsets of the Naturals. Let $r=0.r_1r_2r_3r_4$ be some real numbers written in binary, where $r_j \in \{0,1\}$. Now consider the set $S_r \subset \mathbb{N}$, which corresponds to the number $r$. We define $S$ to consist of all numbers $j$ such that $r_j=1$.

Note that there is also a bijection between the interval $(0,1) \subset \mathbb{R}$ and the whole $\mathbb{R}$.

Acknowledgments

I want to thank Paul Raymond-Robichaud for showing me these results, concisely and cleanly.

 
home about buy book