Over the last years, several readers uncovered mistakes in the *No bullshit guide to math & physics*, which I immediately fixed in the source. The errors were mostly minor, so they didn’t warrant a new edition, but once I reached a threshold of six errata, I decided it’s time to release a v5.1 update. With this bugfix update, I took the time to make some other minor improvements described below.

### Errata

Most of the mistakes in v5 of the book were in the exercises and problems. I’m happy to announce there are no major conceptual problems, or mistakes in any of the core equations. Here are the mistakes in v5.0 (Aug 2014) of the book:

**P1.41**: Both calculations should use the radius instead of the diameter. The change in height is $h_2 – h_1 = 5.47 – 4.41 = 1.06$ cm.**P1.44**: Answer should be 8.42m = $4\sin 40 + \frac{1}{4}(2\pi(0.5)) + 4\cos 40 + 2$.**P1.47**: Answer should be 180 degrees – 40 degrees = 140 degrees.**P1.51**: Question describes the water tank as $12 \times 6 \times 3$, but solution uses $12 \times 6 \times 5$. The question was changed to match the existing solution: the tank now has height $5$[m].**P2.9**part (3) $v_f$ should be 6 [m/s], not 10 [m/s].**P2.10**, part 4. Distance should be 13[m] not 14[m].- page 202: Revolution of the Earth example: $v_t$ should be 328.32 m/s not 464.32 m/s, giving a final answer of 1181.95km/h not 1671.56 km/h.
- 5.5 Limit formulas, page 264 at the bottom: removed formulas $\lim_{x\rightarrow0}\frac{\ln(x+a)}{x}=a$ and $\lim_{x\rightarrow0}\left(a^{1/x}-1\right)=\ln(a)$. First formula is wrong, second is not useful.
- page 286: “Consider the point $P=(x_P,y_P)$ that lies on the circle $x^2+y^2=R$.” should be “Consider the point $P=(x_P,y_P)$ that lies on the circle $x^2+y^2=R^2$.”
- page 401: the correct conversion formula for inch is 1[in] = 2.54[cm] and not 1[T] = 1000[kg].

### New math exercises

Several readers complained about the math fundamentals chapter being too “rough” for complete beginners. To fix this, I did a critical rereading of the material and corrected some mistakes of continuity (there was crazy rough patch in Section 1.2 where I suddenly jump into negative and fractional exponents that—not surprisingly—some readers found confusing). I also interspersed exercises throughout Chapter 1 so readers can now test their understanding as they progress through the chapter.

### Index

Thanks to the suggestion in a comment on amazon, I decided it the book should have an index. It turned out creating an index was a very time-consuming task, but it was very totally worth it since it allowed me to standardize certain terminology (e.g. *function range* vs *function image*) and weed out certain inconsistencies. The exercise of cataloguing every concept used in the book will help with STRUCTURE project too.

### New proof of the chain rule for derivatives

A mathematician friend of mine pointed out a mistake in the proof of the chain rule for derivatives in the book. The hand-wavy argument that I had improvised had possible divide by zero error: the quantity $\Delta = g(x+\delta) – g(x)$ can be zero, so it’s not OK to use it in expressions where it appears in the denominator. In other words, bullshit had creeped into the book! We can’t have any of that in a book which claims to be bullshit free! The new proof of the chain rule for derivatives is longer and more technical, but at least it’s not wrong. Hopefully I will not alienate my readers too much by having such a technical argument in the middle of the calculus chapter, but there really wasn’t any way to make the proof simpler or more intuitive. It’s just a technical argument.

### More calculus problems

Upon critical review, I found the section on surface and volumes of revolution was a little short. Sure all the formulas are introduced, but it would have been a stretch to assume the average reader will be able to pick up the concepts from these few pages. To remedy this, I added a few more pictures, beefed up the discussion, and added some problems. I also came up with a “append only” policy for adding problems to the book—this way the numbers won’t change between versions so if a prof assigns **P5.33** to their students, it will be the same problem in v5, v6, or whenever. The new problems added test the student’s ability to apply the volume of revolution formulas and also the infinite Riemann sum formula.

### The diff

As with previous updates, I’ve generated a red-blue diff of all the changes between v5.0 (Aug 2014) and v5.1 (July 2016). You can check out the diff to see the details of all that changed.

Right now I’m waiting for the green light from my editor about the changes and the next step will be to push the updated PDFs to all distribution channels. I’ll also send out an update email to all readers.

## yisroel lazerson

May 20, 2019 — 12:36 pm

Great book – love it!

Errata: E1.16 answer should be

-log(2)

not:

-log(z)

## Trouble with math? Pi harder! :-)

July 30, 2022 — 2:20 pm

Great book! Thank you so much for putting this together! I’ve been looking for exactly this type of book for a while. Please write more!

One note, I think E2.1 a) and b) may have an error in the answer. The answers don’t take in consideration the initial velocity of the rocket in the time to reach 100 [m/s]. Should be 16 seconds to reach 100 [m/s] for a) and 7 seconds for b) I think. The total distances travelled are off because they use the incorrect time to destination.

## ivan

July 30, 2022 — 5:06 pm

Correct you are!

Please check out the errata file here https://minireference.com/static/errata/noBSmathphys_v5_errata.pdf to apply this fix and others. All fixes thanks to bug reports like yours, so thanks a lot for reporting!